The fact that I'm even having to post this makes me want to punch a kitten. The behavior and communal aspect of this area has gone down the toilet in place of a feel that is crude and elitist, so I'm about to set the record straight to you all.
To do that, I'll need to bring you back to reality by stating that the mods don't take a vacation from any section of the board like you may have thought they did. The
board rules apply everywhere, and blatantly prohibit the sad behavior that has gone down in here. Let me highlight some of the issues and further reinforce what isn't allowed
[center]~*~[/center]
[center]Plagiarism

/center]
Plagiarism is not allowed under any circumstances. It speaks loads about your character and your own skills if you actually have to resort to petty thievery just for the sake of making a good impression to a bunch of people whom you don't know, even more so if you can't even pull it off correctly because your editing skills are just that terrible. If you want to post or use someone else's art for any reason, you must give them proper credit. Otherwise, stop being a lazy git and do your own work. Take the time that the serious artist has taken to continue practicing and upon improving your own skills instead of having the gall to resort to a federal offense.
[center]Criticism

/center]
It is posted in both the site's main rule page and above this section that criticism must be constructive. Here is a
good definition of what actually constitutes constructive criticism:
"Constructive criticism is a compassionate attitude towards the person qualified for criticism. Having higher experience, gifts, respect, knowledge in specific field and being able to verbally convince at the same time, this person is intending to uplift the other person materially, morally, emotionally or spiritually....
There can be tension between constructive and useful criticism; for instance, a critic might usefully help an individual artist to recognize what is poor or slapdash in their body of workbut the critic may have to appear harsh and judgmental in order to state this. But useful criticism is a practical part of constructive criticism."
While you may be harsh or blunt, there should be an obvious element of compassion and respect within the overall criticism. Saying something sucks and then offering a vague, meager way to "fix" it is barely constructive at all. Explain to the person and enlighten. Don't try to destroy their very life and work.
[center]Elitism and Egotism

/center]
This particular highlight is mostly due to the sprite community's outlandish behavior about all of this "recolor" and "custom" nonsense that I honestly couldn't care less about.
If a person chooses to do or start spriting by doing recolors or using existing material to edit, don't you dare look down your nose at them as if your work is some type of magical God-send, because I can guarantee all of you, it's not. There is always someone out there better than you, and you'd be wise to get this fact in your head. As artists, we all need to build up each other's talents and help each other instead of being so negative and judgmental. There's enough of that crap everywhere else, especially in the Sonic community, so we honestly don't need that horrible mentality shoved down our throats any more than it is now. Show some humility for Christ's sake.
And as the ones receiving the criticism, while it is your choice to either take the advice or not, it is entirely unethical to decide how people should post or demand that they do post. No one is under any obligation to reply to your topic or lavish you with petty words of encouragement like you're their prize-winning poodle. This is a place catered to receiving help and advice just as much as it is showing off, and you risk getting a splash of cold, hard truth for posting here. You have no right to determine how one can post, so be prepared for differing opinions and insight to come your way.
So cut this crap out. Jumping down each other's throats for different interests, methods, or skill levels makes you look embarrassingly childish, and telling us how you want us to post or demanding us to reply just for attention is just as pathetic.
[center]~*~[/center]
Let me finish this off by pointing your attention back to this section's rules. Notice how it says that a double penalty will be given in violation of the rules? This will ring true from now on. If you are caught to be stealing, flaming, or breaking any of the other rules of this forum, you will be warned twice. No exceptions. And for those of you who intend on helping us improve the section as a whole, improve your own behavior and report to us those who do not follow the rules.
Now get your damn acts together.