RE: Fancharacters of Greatness V2
BlizShadow > 05-11-2008, 07:55 PM
Well-p, I decided to get another one in. Here's the critique for Renee Cloutier!
=*=
Basic Information: Pretty general stuff. Everything necessary for here is presented, and in a few cases presented well as with the usage of Renee's Latin species name.
Appearance: It's good to see that Renee's appearance has been molded into a lifestyle that is definitely fit for the harshness of surviving in the wilderness: old, tattered clothing, unkempt fur, frequent bloodstains, and a fit and powerful body from her constant movement. It also makes up for the fact that her looks are simply quite boring; there really is no reason for her to stand out, but rather blend in and be general looking.
Personality: Renee is unique in the fact that she is basic. She is out for nothing but self-gratification: cold and calculating, power-thirsty, and cowardly. This type of animal-like personality is one that I don't run up on too often in the fandom, which is very good. However, a minor niggle: the rate at which she descended to such a shocking state of apathy and murderous intent is a little fast, especially since she had been exposed to some sort of civility for the majority of life and is also quite young. This is solidified by the fact that she was tamed for a minute and is actually sentient, so it would be quite possible and realistic that there could be more going through her mind other than finding her next meal.
Abilities: Renee's mana powers are quite nice, as well as the fact that she can use them all in a variety of ways as shown by the large numbers of maneuvers present. You also get major kudos for giving some slight explanation into the biology revolving the cause of her abilities. She also has a decent list of weaknesses; the most notable one being that plain, physical attacks are her greatest obstacle in combat. However, the majority of her move set does not seem to have little repercussions for her using them and many of them involve controlling the character to a certain degree. With the easily devastating effects that these moves can have and the lack of recoil, Renee appears a tad over-balanced.
History: Renee's history is quite interesting considering it explains the leading up to her inevitable and equally-as-interesting descent. It possesses a good flow and is quite well-written, unsurprisingly. The only thing that bothers me about it is a little bit of the internal logic. Renee comes from a very notable family and apparently inherited her powers, but she is cast away because of those very same abilities. If her lineage was notable, then why? I'm a little confused by this, and this only serves to greatly exemplify the riches-to-rags motif; almost to the point where the story has seemed a tad bit shoe-horned in explaining her weird personality. Her lack of family is also a rampant cliche', but overall, I liked her story quite a bit.
Overall: Renee is quite the cool character. The cliche's and bugs present are easily forgiven for a murderous character with an startling apathy that is as sensible as it is horrifying; this animal is totally out of norm of Sonic fan characters. Her rare persona, coupled with bio that is consistent and logical with the themes she presents and exemplifies, makes for a fairly solid character.
8/10