RE: Fancharacters of Greatness V2
Just Avii > 05-11-2008, 02:28 PM
Im weighting my scores.
Sombra the Hedgehog
(25%) Concept: One concept I found within this character was expectations. He was created with the expectation of being a perfect life form, in intelligence, adaptability, fitness. He was also expected to be the perfect weapon of destruction. Finally, he was expected to play savior for other subjugated, artificial life forms. Its all well and good, but the parts of this concept seem overused, and other areas of this character seemed wholly separate. He doesnt seem very consistent at all in his design. 4/10
(30%) Originality: Throughout the bio, only one part truly stood out from the rest as something different; Sombra reads. This isnt a hobby I find in many characters at all, and really made me nod my head in approval; it, and working on his motorcycle, worked well with his lone-wolf character. However, these two parts were crushed under a pile of unoriginality. The first thing I noticed was that Sombra is a hedgehog, and, for me, it takes a lot of effort to pick a character up after that initial species-related drop. Not only that, but while reading I was reminded more and more of Shadow the Hedgehog. Like him, Sombra was created in a lab to be something of an ultimate life form. He was captured and seen as a threat by G.U.N., who also ended up killing a loved one. He was also destined to be a savior in one way or another, said revelation appearing on a recording. Sombra itself means Shadow. Besides blatant shadow references, Sombras other features are hackneyed at best. The angel references seem tacked on, and the play on light and darkness is just as unbecoming of the majority of the rest of him. Again, inconsistency leaves Sombra very unimpressive character. 3/10
(15%) Appearance: Im looking between the hand-drawn and generated pieces for this. Theres nothing outstanding about him. The balance of white and black lends something to the Light and Darkness mentioned in other parts of Sombras biography and is, in that sense, worthy of some credit, but the dark clothing immediately snatches that away. Even making the character black and his clothing white would have been a better chosen, and relatively different, option. I cant give you as many creativity points in that his appearance is exactly from a pre-existing (if individually chosen) format, with little-to-no personal changes to the character. 5/10
(15%) Character (Personality and History): Sombras personality and history are lackluster, at best. He seems horribly cliché, taking the silent, lone-wolf, overly arrogant, antisocial route. The almost-permanently closed eyes habit is a hilarious, not-to-be-taken-seriously tack-on. It seems as though Sombra is the culmination of throwing too many looks-cool-in-anime features into one non-anime character. Sombra could just as easily read to ignore people he wants to ignore, without compromising his eyesight. History wise, Sombra seems like a Re-Character; his past is, at many points, identical to Shadow the Hedgehogs. From creation to capture to death-of-a-friend to realizing true purpose. 2/10
(15%) Balance (Battle): Sombra has his strengths and his weaknesses; the problem is that he has far too many strengths, skills, and abilities and not enough weaknesses and downsides. Sombra has flaming legs that burn anything they touch (accept, for some reason, Sombra). He has swords, guns, exploding cards, two summon-esque angel-things that can tell him when an enemy is making a move or reveal their otherwise unheard plans, pyrokinesis, light/dark-kinesis, combinations of all three kinesi, and- wait for it- a superform. He also has amazing strategic ability. Also, as was mentioned in his history, he and Luz are perfect and great fighters. Overall, Sombra seems like a godmod, and if it werent for the few (mostly move-specific) weakness, he would be considered one. 1/10
Overall Score: 4(.25) + 3(.30) + 5(.15) + 2(.15) +1(.15) = 3.1
(3.1 weighted, 5 unweighted)