RE: Fancharacters of Greatness V2
BlizShadow > 05-12-2008, 02:20 PM
[quote uid=0 name="Chaos Shadow" ]A question.
Why did LilAvii, BlitzShadow said that Sombra is called the ultimate life from which I know darn hell that I said that he is the savior of all life forms, always willing to save one that was created by someone. He also made an army, so explain why you say that he is like Shadow if you see so much things that Shadow doesn't have.
I really believe that 3., and that 5 isn't the right score for Sombra because it seems there are some stuff you have wrote that aren't in his profile.
He does have a tattoo on his back meaning that there is a marking, I am not saying this because I want a higher score, I am saying this because I need to know where are you coming at talking about Sombra is like Shadow.
Shadow knew how to walk, read, and speak when he was first created, but not Sombra, when he was created it was like if he was a baby, getting ready to learn how to speak, and walk.
So yeah explain please, send me a PM, or whatever because I honestly do not agree to see you grading me like that if you seen many stuff on his history that does not compare to what Shadow had.[/quote]
In regards to my review, you'll notice that I never designated Sombra as The Ultimate Life Form nor even used the term at all. Rather, I called him a "prodigious being" since you have designated him as the "savior of life forms". I also said that he has "no extra markings or differentiations to his body to make him look a little more than just the standard hedgehog type.". What I mean by this is that the markings he do have do not make him stand out well enough to me. The tattoo on his back is really nothing special and is a considerably rampant cliche' in the fandom and anime in general. Just for the sake of putting it out there, know that I have no ulterior reason to make things up about your character. I read what is given and grade how I feel accordingly using my own judgement and knowledge.
And I can give ten major reasons I believe that Sombra is too similar to Shadow:
[ul]
[li] He is an artificially-created hedgehog.
[li] He was captured by GUN.
[li] He lost a friend due to GUN's actions.
[li] He has been commanded to be the savior of all life forms; practically the same instruction as Shadow had been given by Maria.
[li] He has many different abilities that are excessively powerful.
[li] He has a type of Super Form.
[li] He exemplifies the theme of "light vs. dark."
[li] He has been designated as a tool without regard to his sentience.
[li] He is essentially a lone-wolf: silent, extremely intelligent, cold, and calculating.
[li] He has a knack at using weaponry and vehicles despite being gifted with extraordinary abilities.
[li]His name literally means "shadow".[/b]
[/li][/ul]These are some of the most major attributes that make up Sombra. If the list above is any indication, the similarities to Shadow are just mind-boggling, and I simply feel that you did not supplement this with enough of your own creative logic or manage to avoid many of the taboos regarding Sonic fan characters to convince me that Sombra is a character worthy of a higher score.