RE: Need a little help with story writing
Katsuko > 07-24-2008, 08:45 PM
I suppose there are alot of paths you could take. My suggestion would be to step back, and forget Sonic and Shadow, and just think about ordinary people. What might you and someone at school get into a fight about? What causes conflicts between your parents? Why do men fight in general? Why do nations go to war? What makes enemies?
At the bottom of it, if you don't want Sonic to be a villain, then you'll have to have some sort of conflict where both sides can be understood. People can understand both sides of the argument--but what will make the protagonist different, is the way he goes out to achieve his goal.
I think that's what you want to go for here. Both Sonic and Shadow get into a disagreement over something that the reader can understand both sides for. Perhaps their perspective on something, say a crime, leads them to disagree over something. Suppose Sonic saw this crime, and was convinced that the man was guilty of murder (or something), and deserved to be punished. Shadow, on the other hand, had some sort of completely different perspective, that convinced him that the man was innocent. So, of course Sonic goes chasing after this man, and Shadow has to try and stop him from doing any harm.
Of course, that's only one scenario. Still, something like that would be my suggestion
Now one thing that I think is very important here, is that the reader should not know who's right, at first, perhaps for the majority of the story. I think that for this to work, people have to be able to sympathize with both Shadow and Sonic, which would require that they not know that Sonic was wrong. What should be different, however, is Sonic and Shadow's attitude about the conflict. Since Shadow is your protagonist, he should have a very likable, very reasonable approach, while Sonic, perhaps, would have a much more unreasonable, much more violent approach; he's willing to sacrifice anything, including his morals, to see to it that what is right in his mind is done. This will alienate the readers, and perhaps serve to get Amy to break up with him.
That's the other thing I'm thinking: Perhaps this story should be told from Amy's perspective, instead of Shadow's, or at least done so that Amy's attitude = reader's. Even though the reader and Amy can understand why Sonic thinks what he thinks, they cannot agree with the selfish, or violent, or irrational way he goes about trying to do what is, in his mind, the right thing. Sonic is likable, but he's vehement that he's right, and he refuses to hear anything else. Meanwhile, Shadow will draw the attention of Amy and the reader by doing the exact opposite. Perhaps we will even be lead to believe that Shadow is wrong, and Sonic is right, but we'll want Shadow to be right just because his approach is so much more likable and sensible.
Anyway, that's how I'd do it.