RE: Fancharacters of Greatness V2
BlizShadow > 05-13-2008, 08:17 PM
X3;; Maerw, that review was quite humbling. Thank you, Avid. <333
Now, onto Lio's critique.
=*=
Basic Information: The thing that immediately struck me as odd is that while Lio has a definite birthday, we're given a range instead of a precise number for his age. That's a little bit sloppy, especially since the age is arguably one of the easiest pieces of information to input for a character, but overall the rest of the information is fine, if a bit vague.
Appearance: Lio's appearance is severely disappointing as male lions are some of the most notable and beautiful of the big cats, and Lio's origins from a tribal village could have provided grand inspiration for some eye-popping design. The descriptions are either as basic as they can be or simply unacceptable with their sheer vagueness. A bit of the information is also contradictory to the picture given: in the former, we are told that he has no outfit but can see in the picture that he at least wears shoes and gloves. He does not really give the impression of a male lion, either; rather being a mix and match of fox and hedgehog qualities. While I recognize this as a limitation of the character generator you used, the lack of good description just leaves me hanging; almost saddened.
Personality: Lio, to me, seems to be something of a mixed bag, although he leans a bit on the loner/badass side of things. He is stubborn, likes to lead people, easily gets enraged, seems to make pretty reasonable decisions overall, and does not care much for loss or relationships.... And it seems that's about it. There's not a whole lot to say about him in this area, unfortunately. Simply put, he has a relatively mediocre and boring personality, simply because he's much too underdeveloped for me to want to learn and even talk about this character.
Abilities: It is quite surprising to see that Lio isn't endowed with too many abilities. Not a lot of fan characters come with as simple a move set nor rely as heavily on brute force. Unfortunately, the few moves he does have are just overpowered beyond the max. Lio supersedes the taboo of outdoing the official characters by light-years with his speed as not even Sonic in his base state is as fast as a laser. He can also deflect any object, missiles included, which gives him a nearly perfect defense. These moves also have no repercussions for use. And then, there's his single weakness of water, which I see no point to. The likelihood of him being exposed to it when he could easily gather the speed to get across a body of water or dodge an elemental attack practically nullifies its existence in the first place.
History: It took a little hard-core reading in order to grasp the finer points of his background because the writing is a little confusing, especially in the beginning where Lio's hate seems to be directed at the most convenient of places without any logical advancement or good pacing. The cliche' use of powerful artifacts, Lio's wave of destruction, the random amount of underdeveloped characters thrown around, and the fact that he was heavily involved with the Sonic cast and the Chaos Emeralds, therefore nearly shattering the canon to bits, were also some things that were very off-putting. The only thing I can say I do like about his story is that his living around in the after life is somewhat interesting, although this little spark of creativity seems shoe-horned as well since it is not reflected anywhere else in the bio.
Overall: Unfortunately, Lio comes off as an overwhelming disappointment amidst the vague and contradictory details, overpowered abilities, a lack of inner logic and cohesion, and a history that ignores the very basic "do's and don'ts" in the art of creating Sonic fan characters. There is little else to say, other than utterly massive amounts of work needs to be done to the character in order to even be considered for a passing score.
2/10